I have a few weeks of following Weight Watchers under my belt now, and I am over the initial shock of just how many points my favorite foods are worth. The first week was a jolt, and I had to overhaul my eating habits fast. Soda is worth way too many points and left nothing if I actually wanted to eat that day. Candy, sweets, anything sugary and gooey and rotting my teeth (in other words, my favorite foods) had to go.
Most fruits and vegetables are “free”, meaning they have no points. I can eat them and not lose any points for the day. So I started packing things like bananas and grapes for my snacks during the work day, and I add celery and carrots to my lunches. I spring for the points for ranch dressing, because otherwise I know damn good and well I won’t eat the rabbit food. No diet or ranch dressing, either, because it tastes like doo-doo.
After struggling for months to get back on track, the WW points system basically slapped me in the face and said “Either crap or get off the pot”. I had to either make big changes to stick to my points, or I could waste the money I was spending on WW, keep eating whatever I wanted, and keep gaining weight. I don’t know why the points system made it click for me when tracking calories didn’t. Maybe just because it was something new. I am just grateful I found something that drastically improved my eating habits and got me back to losing weight.
I joined WW while they were running a special price for 3 months, so my membership will expire in mid-January. WW is a bit expensive when they aren’t running specials, so I am already contemplating whether I want to renew in January or not.
Thing is, I definitely credit the WW points for getting me back on track, but the WW site and app are just not worth $20 a month. My food diary is not broken down into macros like fiber, carbs, protein, calcium, etc. The features like saving a meal or adding favorite food to MyFitnessPal seems much easier too. It takes me less time to log my food on MFP than it does on WW. Editing or deleting my saved meals is easier on MFP too.
The WW app and site don’t come with much of a community, either. There’s a feature called Connect where you can see posts and pictures from other people, and you can follow certain people, but it’s not the same. There’s no feed specific to me, with just my posts and my friends’ posts, like on MFP. I can’t “friend” people like I can on MyFitnessPal, can’t send messages like I can on MFP. There are no message boards or challenges at all on WW, which is huge strike against them for me.
In a nutshell, the only benefit the WW app and site have for me is quickly calculating the WW points for my food diary. The community and the support are simply not there, and free sites like MFP have more features on the food diary than WW does for $20 a month. Nothing justifies the cost for me. The WW app feels primitive, which is ironic since it is the most expensive food logging app that I know of. If MFP and LoseIt can offer more features on even their free accounts, then WW has no excuse to not offer the same, and more, with their overpriced app.
I thought about cancelling WW and getting at least a partial refund of what I paid for 3 months, but I am still not 100% on my feet. I know how easily I can slide back into bad habits. For some reason, the WW points are keeping me in line, and if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it. I will keep it through January and hopefully get stronger in my healthier habits so I can just switch back to logging my food on MFP, with better eating habits.
I’m not running WW down here. I love what tracking WW points has done to improve my eating habits and get me back on track. But for $20 a month for online only (the website and the app, no meetings), WW really needs to offer more. Free apps are more sophisticated, easier to navigate, and offer more features and support.
I have been double-logging my food, entering it into WW to track my points, then entering it into MFP to track calories. It’s extra work, but I wanted to keep a record of how many calories I am consuming compared to how many WW points I am using each day. I think it will help when I switch back to logging on just MFP. A day with the same calorie range as another day, but with lower WW points, means I ate healthier that day. So later I can review my MFP food diary and see which days were the most successful for me, and I already have a meal plan to follow. It’s a pain to double-log, but when I cancel WW, I think it will be valuable to me to have that information saved on MFP. (I use the Notes box to enter my WW points for that day).
I have now officially smothered you in WW talk 🙂 I like to plan ahead, though, and I figured maybe someone else could benefit from a review of the WW app compared to free ones like MFP. Bottom line, it is worth every penny to me to pay for the WW app for a few months to get me back on track, but I can’t see indefinitely paying $20 a month for outdated and limited tools. WW really needs to add features to make it more than a points calculator.